Abstract

Primary retroperitoneal mucinous cystic tumor (PRMCT) is rare and preoperative diagnosis is challenging due to their rarity, lack of specific diagnostic imaging, clinical presentation, and tumor markers. We present an extremely rare case of PRMCT of borderline malignancy and summarize the characteristics of previously reported cases. Although the prognosis and optimal therapeutic strategies require further investigation due to its rarity, we should be considered when dealing with retroperitoneal cystic lesions.

Introduction

Primary retroperitoneal mucinous cystic tumors (PRMCT), including mucinous cystadenoma, mucinous cystic tumor of borderline malignancy (PBMCTB), and mucinous cystadenocarcinoma, are a very rare entity [1–3]. Since they are not commonly recognized, preoperative diagnosis is challenging. This case report aims to contribute to the understanding of this rare entity and to aid in making accurate preoperative diagnoses.

Case report

A 50-year-old female patient initially presented 3 years ago with uterine myoma. At that time, retroperitoneal enhanced computed tomography scan revealed multiple uterine myomas and an 8.0 × 5.8 cm lobulated cystic mass with smooth border in the left lower retroperitoneum (Fig. 1a). The cystic mass was suspected to be a retroperitoneal lymphangioma, and since there were no symptoms related to it, the patient decided to undergo observation rather than surgical removal. Since then, size, number, and feature of myomas and retroperitoneal mass showed no change in the follow-up annual CT (Fig. 1b). Recently, although the patient had no specific symptoms related to the cystic tumor, she felt that her abdomen was gradually becoming more bloated. As a result, she opted for surgical removal. The evaluation for serum tumor markers was not conducted. The surgically resected tumor was a large-sized, well-demarcated multilocular cyst with multifocal wall calcification, measuring 142 g and 10.5 × 6.8 × 4.5 cm. There were no ascites, lymphadenopathy, or adhesion to surrounding organs. Both ovaries were normal. The cyst contained clear mucinous fluid and showed focal papillary excrescences, measuring 2.4 × 2.0 cm. Microscopically, the cyst was mainly lined by a single layer of mucin-secreting columnar epithelium (Fig. 2a). In papillary excrescences, papillae lined by stratified mucinous epithelium with moderate nuclear atypia were observed (Fig. 2b). The tumor cells were positive for cytokeratin 7, and negative for cytokeratin 20 and calretinin. Ovarian-like stroma was found and showed positivity for estrogen receptor. No stromal invasion was found. Histologic diagnosis was PRMCTB. During a follow-up period of 24 months, there was no recurrence or metastasis.

(a) Retroperitoneal enhanced CT shows a lobulated homogeneous cyst in the left lower abdomen. (b) A year later, there was no change in the size, shape, or characteristics of the cyst.
Figure 1

(a) Retroperitoneal enhanced CT shows a lobulated homogeneous cyst in the left lower abdomen. (b) A year later, there was no change in the size, shape, or characteristics of the cyst.

(a) Mucinous cystadenoma with a single layer of columnar epithelium with abundant intracellular mucin (HE, 4×). (b) PBMCTB shows papillary growth of stratified mucinous epithelium with nuclear atypia (HE, 4×).
Figure 2

(a) Mucinous cystadenoma with a single layer of columnar epithelium with abundant intracellular mucin (HE, 4×). (b) PBMCTB shows papillary growth of stratified mucinous epithelium with nuclear atypia (HE, 4×).

Discussion

PRMCTs, including mucinous cystadenoma, PBMCTB, and mucinous cystadenocarcinoma are very rare entity and resemble ovarian mucinous cystic tumors [1–3].

Preoperative diagnosis of PRMCT is difficult due to the lack of specific clinical presentation, laboratory findings, or pathognomonic radiologic features [4]. Several hypotheses regarding the origin of PRMCT have been suggested but remain uncertain [2, 5–7]. The one is that PRMCT arises from ectopic ovarian tissue due to the histologic similarity with ovary mucinous cystic tumor. However, PRMCT has been reported in men and most of them did not contain ovarian tissue. Another is that PRMCT originates from teratoma or remnants of embryonal urogenital apparatus. However, the most widely accepted hypothesis is that PRMCT arises from invaginated peritoneal mesothelium, which undergoes subsequent mucinous metaplasia leading to cyst formation [2, 5].

We searched the reported cases of PRMCTB using PubMed and reviewed 28 cases without carcinoma component (Table 1). Including this case, twenty-three cases were women, and 6 were men. The median age was 43.8 years (22 to 68 years). The most common symptom was nonspecific abdominal pain and distension, and it predominantly appeared as a unilocular or multilocular cyst of variable size on imaging. Tumor markers, such as CA125, CA19-9, and CEA were not useful for diagnosis. Six cases revealed ovarian-like stroma, which suggests that female hormone may affect the development or growth of PRMCT [8]. All the tumors were removed through complete total resection, and their sizes ranged from 2 to 28 cm (mean, 14.96 cm). When reviewing the 29 reported cases so far, follow-up data for 20 patients were available, with an average follow-up period of 22.4 months (range: 1–148 months). During this period, one patient experienced a recurrence, and another patient had mediastinal lymph node metastasis. Due to the rarity and the lack of long-term follow-up data, it is difficult to determine the patient's prognosis of the PRMCTB. The management of PRMCTB is not yet well-established, but the best approach is complete surgical tumor removal. During surgery to remove the cystic mass, it is important to prevent rupture or spillage of cystic contents to reduce peritoneal dissemination and tumor recurrence [9]. Adjuvant chemotherapy after tumor resection also remains controversial. Some recommended just close follow-up, while others suggested treatment based on its histologically similar ovarian cancer [3, 4, 10, 11].

Table 1

Clinical features of previously reported cases of primary PBMCTB

Age/SexSymptomLocationImaging findingSize (cm)Outcome (months)
41/FAbdominal pain and tumorNDND12 × 10 × 9NED (ND)
38/FAbdominal pain and distensionLeft lower abdomenMultilocular cyst11Mediastinal node metastasis (48 months)
47/FLUQ massLeft upper quadrantND13ND
63/MAbdominal painRight kidneyCyst11ND
62/FAbdominal painRight flankHypodense mass12 × 8.5NED (18 months)
68/MRight abdominal massRight abdomenCyst16 × 14.5 × 10NED
65/FAbdominal distensionLeft abdominal cavityMultilocular cyst21 × 14NED (12 months)
32/MIncidental on radiologyAround vena cavaND7 × 6 × 4.4ND
44/MAbdominal painInteraortocavalMultiple retroperitoneal massMultiple (2–5)NED (12 months)
35/FPelvic painRear of the cecumCyst28NED (24 months)
22/FAbdominal painSuperior of uterusCyst20 × 17.5 × 15NED (24 months)
33/FAbdominal pain, swellingLeft flankCystNDNED (10 months)
33/FTirednessDescending colonCyst15 × 13 × 9NED (12 months)
48/FPostprandial fullnessAscending colon mesenteryCyst15 × 13 × 9NED (8 months)
41/FFlank painRight upper quadrantCyst21 × 16NED (18 months)
31/FAbdominal distensionRight retroperitoneal spaceMultilocular cyst21 × 16 × 10ND
36/FAbdominal distensionRight lower abdomenCyst12 × 8NED (6 months)
39/MBack painLeft pararenal spaceCyst6.9 × 4.4NED
56/FPainful urinationRight kidneyMultilocular cyst28 × 22 × 8Recur (6 months later)
45/FAbdominal painLeft lower abdomenCyst with nodule15NED (12 months)
25/FKidney massNDCyst with papillae15NED (148 months)
43/FPelvic painNDCyst with papillae14NED (1 months)
48/FEnlarged massNDMultilocular cyst7NED (34 months)
37/MAbdominal pain, massRight abdomenMultilocular cyst22 × 11NED (12 months)
26/FAbdominal distension, painLeft lower quadrantCyst13 × 10 × 8ND
65/FMassNDSeptate cystNDNED (6 months)
23/FMassNDCystNDND
68/FPalpable abdominal massLeft kidneyMultilocular cyst15 × 11 × 9NED (12 months)
56/F (this)Incidental on radiologyRetroperitoneumUnilocular cyst8 × 5NED (24 months)
Age/SexSymptomLocationImaging findingSize (cm)Outcome (months)
41/FAbdominal pain and tumorNDND12 × 10 × 9NED (ND)
38/FAbdominal pain and distensionLeft lower abdomenMultilocular cyst11Mediastinal node metastasis (48 months)
47/FLUQ massLeft upper quadrantND13ND
63/MAbdominal painRight kidneyCyst11ND
62/FAbdominal painRight flankHypodense mass12 × 8.5NED (18 months)
68/MRight abdominal massRight abdomenCyst16 × 14.5 × 10NED
65/FAbdominal distensionLeft abdominal cavityMultilocular cyst21 × 14NED (12 months)
32/MIncidental on radiologyAround vena cavaND7 × 6 × 4.4ND
44/MAbdominal painInteraortocavalMultiple retroperitoneal massMultiple (2–5)NED (12 months)
35/FPelvic painRear of the cecumCyst28NED (24 months)
22/FAbdominal painSuperior of uterusCyst20 × 17.5 × 15NED (24 months)
33/FAbdominal pain, swellingLeft flankCystNDNED (10 months)
33/FTirednessDescending colonCyst15 × 13 × 9NED (12 months)
48/FPostprandial fullnessAscending colon mesenteryCyst15 × 13 × 9NED (8 months)
41/FFlank painRight upper quadrantCyst21 × 16NED (18 months)
31/FAbdominal distensionRight retroperitoneal spaceMultilocular cyst21 × 16 × 10ND
36/FAbdominal distensionRight lower abdomenCyst12 × 8NED (6 months)
39/MBack painLeft pararenal spaceCyst6.9 × 4.4NED
56/FPainful urinationRight kidneyMultilocular cyst28 × 22 × 8Recur (6 months later)
45/FAbdominal painLeft lower abdomenCyst with nodule15NED (12 months)
25/FKidney massNDCyst with papillae15NED (148 months)
43/FPelvic painNDCyst with papillae14NED (1 months)
48/FEnlarged massNDMultilocular cyst7NED (34 months)
37/MAbdominal pain, massRight abdomenMultilocular cyst22 × 11NED (12 months)
26/FAbdominal distension, painLeft lower quadrantCyst13 × 10 × 8ND
65/FMassNDSeptate cystNDNED (6 months)
23/FMassNDCystNDND
68/FPalpable abdominal massLeft kidneyMultilocular cyst15 × 11 × 9NED (12 months)
56/F (this)Incidental on radiologyRetroperitoneumUnilocular cyst8 × 5NED (24 months)

ND, not described; NED, no evidence of disease

Table 1

Clinical features of previously reported cases of primary PBMCTB

Age/SexSymptomLocationImaging findingSize (cm)Outcome (months)
41/FAbdominal pain and tumorNDND12 × 10 × 9NED (ND)
38/FAbdominal pain and distensionLeft lower abdomenMultilocular cyst11Mediastinal node metastasis (48 months)
47/FLUQ massLeft upper quadrantND13ND
63/MAbdominal painRight kidneyCyst11ND
62/FAbdominal painRight flankHypodense mass12 × 8.5NED (18 months)
68/MRight abdominal massRight abdomenCyst16 × 14.5 × 10NED
65/FAbdominal distensionLeft abdominal cavityMultilocular cyst21 × 14NED (12 months)
32/MIncidental on radiologyAround vena cavaND7 × 6 × 4.4ND
44/MAbdominal painInteraortocavalMultiple retroperitoneal massMultiple (2–5)NED (12 months)
35/FPelvic painRear of the cecumCyst28NED (24 months)
22/FAbdominal painSuperior of uterusCyst20 × 17.5 × 15NED (24 months)
33/FAbdominal pain, swellingLeft flankCystNDNED (10 months)
33/FTirednessDescending colonCyst15 × 13 × 9NED (12 months)
48/FPostprandial fullnessAscending colon mesenteryCyst15 × 13 × 9NED (8 months)
41/FFlank painRight upper quadrantCyst21 × 16NED (18 months)
31/FAbdominal distensionRight retroperitoneal spaceMultilocular cyst21 × 16 × 10ND
36/FAbdominal distensionRight lower abdomenCyst12 × 8NED (6 months)
39/MBack painLeft pararenal spaceCyst6.9 × 4.4NED
56/FPainful urinationRight kidneyMultilocular cyst28 × 22 × 8Recur (6 months later)
45/FAbdominal painLeft lower abdomenCyst with nodule15NED (12 months)
25/FKidney massNDCyst with papillae15NED (148 months)
43/FPelvic painNDCyst with papillae14NED (1 months)
48/FEnlarged massNDMultilocular cyst7NED (34 months)
37/MAbdominal pain, massRight abdomenMultilocular cyst22 × 11NED (12 months)
26/FAbdominal distension, painLeft lower quadrantCyst13 × 10 × 8ND
65/FMassNDSeptate cystNDNED (6 months)
23/FMassNDCystNDND
68/FPalpable abdominal massLeft kidneyMultilocular cyst15 × 11 × 9NED (12 months)
56/F (this)Incidental on radiologyRetroperitoneumUnilocular cyst8 × 5NED (24 months)
Age/SexSymptomLocationImaging findingSize (cm)Outcome (months)
41/FAbdominal pain and tumorNDND12 × 10 × 9NED (ND)
38/FAbdominal pain and distensionLeft lower abdomenMultilocular cyst11Mediastinal node metastasis (48 months)
47/FLUQ massLeft upper quadrantND13ND
63/MAbdominal painRight kidneyCyst11ND
62/FAbdominal painRight flankHypodense mass12 × 8.5NED (18 months)
68/MRight abdominal massRight abdomenCyst16 × 14.5 × 10NED
65/FAbdominal distensionLeft abdominal cavityMultilocular cyst21 × 14NED (12 months)
32/MIncidental on radiologyAround vena cavaND7 × 6 × 4.4ND
44/MAbdominal painInteraortocavalMultiple retroperitoneal massMultiple (2–5)NED (12 months)
35/FPelvic painRear of the cecumCyst28NED (24 months)
22/FAbdominal painSuperior of uterusCyst20 × 17.5 × 15NED (24 months)
33/FAbdominal pain, swellingLeft flankCystNDNED (10 months)
33/FTirednessDescending colonCyst15 × 13 × 9NED (12 months)
48/FPostprandial fullnessAscending colon mesenteryCyst15 × 13 × 9NED (8 months)
41/FFlank painRight upper quadrantCyst21 × 16NED (18 months)
31/FAbdominal distensionRight retroperitoneal spaceMultilocular cyst21 × 16 × 10ND
36/FAbdominal distensionRight lower abdomenCyst12 × 8NED (6 months)
39/MBack painLeft pararenal spaceCyst6.9 × 4.4NED
56/FPainful urinationRight kidneyMultilocular cyst28 × 22 × 8Recur (6 months later)
45/FAbdominal painLeft lower abdomenCyst with nodule15NED (12 months)
25/FKidney massNDCyst with papillae15NED (148 months)
43/FPelvic painNDCyst with papillae14NED (1 months)
48/FEnlarged massNDMultilocular cyst7NED (34 months)
37/MAbdominal pain, massRight abdomenMultilocular cyst22 × 11NED (12 months)
26/FAbdominal distension, painLeft lower quadrantCyst13 × 10 × 8ND
65/FMassNDSeptate cystNDNED (6 months)
23/FMassNDCystNDND
68/FPalpable abdominal massLeft kidneyMultilocular cyst15 × 11 × 9NED (12 months)
56/F (this)Incidental on radiologyRetroperitoneumUnilocular cyst8 × 5NED (24 months)

ND, not described; NED, no evidence of disease

In conclusion, although PRMCTB is rare entity, we need to be aware of this borderline tumor, as it can transform into mucinous cystadenocarcinoma, and early detection is crucial for appropriate treatment.

Conflict of interest statement

None declared.

Funding

None declared.

Ethical approval

The study was approved by the ethics committee of Yeungnam University College of Medicine. The patient consent waiver was approved by the Institutional Review Board (IRB).

References

1.

Toffolo Pasquini
 
M
,
Aragone
 
L
,
Scasso Rebdza
 
V
, et al.  
Primary retroperitoneal tumor: mucinous cystoadenocarcinoma
.
Medicina (B Aires)
 
2024
;
84
:
750
5
.

2.

Roma
 
AA
,
Malpica
 
A
.
Primary retroperitoneal mucinous tumors: a clinicopathologic study of 18 cases
.
Am J Surg Pathol
 
2009
;
33
:
526
33
. .

3.

Matsubara
 
M
,
Shiozawa
 
T
,
Tachibana
 
R
, et al.  
Primary retroperitoneal mucinous cystadenoma of borderline malignancy: a case report and review of the literature
.
Int J Gynecol Pathol
 
2005
;
24
:
218
23
. .

4.

Bifulco
 
G
,
Mandato
 
VD
,
Giampaolino
 
P
, et al.  
Huge primary retroperitoneal mucinous cystadenoma of borderline malignancy mimicking an ovarian mass: case report and review
.
Anticancer Res
 
2008
;
28
:
2309
15
.

5.

Vargas
 
AC
,
Lam
 
V
,
P'Ng
 
CH
.
A rare case of primary retroperitoneal mucinous neoplasm in a male patient
.
Pathology
 
2015
;
47
:
384
6
. .

6.

Son
 
SM
,
Woo
 
CG
,
Yun
 
SJ
, et al.  
Primary retroperitoneal mucinous cystic neoplasm of borderline malignancy with KRAS and GNAS co-mutation: a case report
.
J Int Med Res
 
2023
;
51
:3000605231172469. .

7.

Zhang
 
J
,
Zeng
 
Q
,
Kang
 
J
, et al.  
Primary retroperitoneal mucinous cystic tumour of borderline malignancy mimicking kidney duplicate: cases report and literature review
.
BMC Urol
 
2023
;
23
:
32
. .

8.

Tomisaki
 
I
,
Matsuyama
 
A
,
Jotatsu
 
M
, et al.  
Primary retroperitoneal mucinous cystadenocarcinoma with transition from the mesothelium
.
IJU Case Rep
 
2020
;
3
:
137
40
. .

9.

Kavanagh
 
TR
,
Nwaoduah
 
N
,
Richard
 
SD
, et al.  
Surgical resection of a rare primary retroperitoneal mucinous borderline tumor of Mullerian origin: a case report
.
Gynecol Oncol Rep
 
2022
;
44
:
101104
. .

10.

Pearl
 
ML
,
Valea
 
F
,
Chumas
 
J
, et al.  
Primary retroperitoneal mucinous cystadenocarcinoma of low malignant potential: a case report and literature review
.
Gynecol Oncol
 
1996
;
61
:
150
2
. .

11.

Lee
 
SE
,
Oh
 
HC
,
Park
 
YG
, et al.  
Laparoscopic excision of primary retroperitoneal mucinous cystadenoma and malignant predicting factors derived from literature review
.
Int J Surg Case Rep
 
2015
;
9
:
130
3
. .

This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution Non-Commercial License (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/), which permits non-commercial re-use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited. For commercial re-use, please contact journals.permissions@oup.com